Make A Payment

Make a Payment

To make a payment on your insurance policy, please send a check to your insurance company directly. If you are having trouble finding where your payment should be sent, please contact us directly. To see more information about a company, click on its logo. Some of the companies we represent accept payments online.

Aegis
Phone: 800-233-2160

Allstate
Phone: 1-800-255-7828

American Modern
Phone: 800-543-2644

ASI / Progressive Home
Phone: 866-274-8765

Auto-Owners
Phone: 1-800-346-0346

Berkshire Hathaway
Phone: 1-800-673-2465

Celina
Phone: 800-552-5181

Dairyland
Phone: 800-334-0090

Donegal
Phone: 800-877-0600

Encova
Phone: 844-362-6821

Foremost
Phone: 800-527-3905

Founders Insurance
Phone: 800-972-8778

Grange
Phone: 800-422-0550

Grinnell
Phone: 800-362-2041

Hagerty
Phone: 800-922-4050

The Hartford
Phone: 860-547-5000

Hastings Mutual
Phone: 800-442-8277

MAPFRE
Phone: 800-222-2114

MAX MutualAid eXchange
Phone: 877-971-6300

Mennonite Mutual
Phone: 1-800-678-6885

Nationwide
Phone: 1-877-669-6877

Ohio FAIR Plan
Phone: 1-800-282-1772

Ohio Mutual
Phone: 800-686-3011

Progressive
Phone: 1-800-776-4737

State Auto
Phone: 1-833-724-3577

United Fire Group
Phone: 800-637-6309

Wayne Insurance
Phone: 1-800-255-7828

Western Reserve Group
Phone: 1-800-362-0426

Woodville Mutual
Phone: 419-849-2521

Wyandot Mutual
Phone: 800-456-0873